“Germany is an anatomical oddity,” Kurt Tucholsky once wrote. “It writes with its left hand and acts with its right.” He would have known. As the most prominent columnist of the Weimar Republic, he skewered the fashions and follies of the newly ascendant right wing in reams of satirical essays, poems and cabaret songs under five different bylines. In his day, he was as famous as the kings of American late-night comedy are now — and just as powerless to affect elections.
With hindsight, some critics wondered if his sendups of Nazi bigwigs and fascist foot soldiers hadn’t been a little too funny, like the poem “Joebbels,” which in thick Berlin dialect deflates the Führer’s diminutive propaganda minister, or a spoof Hitler Youth essay weighing who was the greater German, Goethe or Hitler. Maybe such antics helped make the Nazis look harmless. In any case readers laughed. And Hitler still won.
By then Tucholsky had already chosen a life in exile, first in Paris, then in Sweden. Bitterly aware of his own impotence, he stopped writing and fell into depression.
But in 1931, two years before members of the Hitler Youth hurled his books onto a bonfire, and four years before overdosing on sleeping pills, Tucholsky wrote a love story as light as a summer breeze. Not much happens in CASTLE GRIPSHOLM, which New York Review Books has just reissued in a sympathetic translation by Michael Hofmann, though there is enough witty banter, fresh air and sex to propel the story along. The lingering power of this deceptively slight novel comes from the shiver of foreboding that courses through it.
A writer (named Tucholsky) and his girlfriend, Lydia, both hard-bitten city dwellers, vacation in the Swedish countryside. Nothing mars their idyll — not even pompous fellow tourists and overpriced booze — until they discover a girl who is being tyrannized in a nearby boarding school. Reluctant at first, they soon find that they cannot turn their backs on her suffering. But will they be able to make much of a difference?
By the time Tucholsky wrote “Castle Gripsholm” in Sweden, that question had become painfully personal. Born into a prosperous Jewish family in Berlin, he quickly showed talent as a polemicist. (While still in school he published a mock fairy tale poking fun at Kaiser Wilhelm’s taste in art.)
Tucholsky studied law and served on the Eastern Front in World War I, an experience that forged his lifelong pacifism. Though the targets of his satire included the class bias of the Weimar legal system, puffed-up writing and the vacuity of popular music, most of his efforts were directed at the boorishness of the nascent Third Reich.
“A satirist,” Tucholsky once wrote, “is an offended idealist.” In “Castle Gripsholm” that idealism comes out to play once more, in a bucolic setting of “blue skies and gray skies, sun, sea-breath, fish and whiskey.” Kurt (whom Lydia calls Peter) and Lydia (whom he calls Princess) are at the sweet spot of a relationship. They are already “intimate, but not bored; new, but not too new; fresh, but not strange.”
Their relationship is buoyed more by breezy tenderness than ardor. Then Lydia’s friend Billie shows up and a crossword puzzle at bedtime sparks passions that surprise all of them.
Meanwhile, they can’t get out of their minds the girl they saw, visibly terrified, on an outing with her classmates. Her school and its sadistic German matron become a symbol of all that is wrong with the Weimar Republic in its death throes. When the vacationers step in to extract the girl from her ordeal, they do so knowing full well that they are leaving no dent in the institution of oppression.
According to one Jewish proverb, a man who saves one life saves the whole world. Tucholsky was too much of a realist to subscribe to that view. Yet he let nobody off the hook.
Consider this passage about the “quiet, thoughtful” craftsmen who built the boarding school that harbors so much suffering: “When it was finished, they plastered the walls, and some of the rooms were painted, many more were papered, all differently, and according to their instructions. Then they had gone away phlegmatically. The house was finished; it didn’t matter what happened in it now. That wasn’t their affair, they were only the builders. The courtroom where people are tortured was, to begin with, a rectangle of brick walls, smooth and whitewashed. A painter had stood on his ladder and whistled cheerfully as he painted a gray stripe right round the room, as he had been told to; as far as he was concerned, it was a piece of craftsmanship.”
Tucholsky’s verdict on his own ability to change things with his pen was devastating. In 1923 he wrote, “I have success, but no impact whatsoever.”
But outside politics his impact on his contemporaries was profound. Some of his quips remain in circulation to this day. His mix of snark and forensic social observation defined a certain brand of cool for the interwar generation. And, long before Lydia, he defined as a feminine ideal a woman who was outwardly capricious and ditsy, yet levelheaded, warm and fiercely independent.
The prototype was Claire, the protagonist of the illustrated novella “Rheinsberg,” which Tucholsky published in 1912 when he was barely 22. It prefigures “Castle Gripsholm,” featuring a young couple vacationing in the countryside where they bicker in a patois of their own devising, make love and poke fun at bourgeois mores. The book was a runaway success. For a while, Tucholsky and the book’s illustrator ran a pop-up store in Berlin where customers were served a shot of schnapps with each purchase. German couples adopted Claire’s droll mix of colloquial dialect and hapless High German, as their private language.
In both “Rheinsberg” and “Castle Gripsholm” Tucholsky uses patois to heighten the daffy sex appeal of his female characters. In “Castle Gripsholm,” it is Lydia’s use of Missingsch, a customizable blend of High German and the earthy Platt dialect of northern Germany, that reveals her no-nonsense character. As the narrator describes Missingsch, “it slithers about on the carefully wax-polished stairs of German grammar, before falling flat on its face in its beloved Platt.” In this translation, Hofmann forgoes any attempt at finding an English equivalent. In his introduction he writes that trying to render Missingsch using a “‘corresponding’ dialect” in English would be “distracting, paradoxical, absurd.” He cites Tucholsky’s own disdain for a German translation of “Lady Chatterley’s Lover” that had Mellors speaking in a “‘Bavarian mountain dialect.’”
Instead, Hofmann alerts us when a character is speaking Platt and then gives a straightforward translation. (It’s the same strategy that Elena Ferrante used in her Neapolitan novels, where she tells, but never shows, the reader when one of her characters speaks in dialect.)
In any case Tucholsky doesn’t resort to dialect for the fun of it. Rather, he does so out of a strong allergy to nationalist pathos.
To the narrator of “Castle Gripsholm,” the remaining pockets of Platt speakers are like “a dream world of eccentricity, kindness and music, inhabited by an assortment of people like rare beetles, each one of them unique.” In this work, written shortly before Tucholsky slipped into self-imposed silence, he fashions a dream world for his idealized characters. He creates a language like a hamlet. Population: two.
“Anyone can manage to be happy for a brief time,” the narrator says near the end as he and Lydia head to the night ferry that will take them through the darkness and back toward Germany. “A brief happiness: None other is conceivable, here on earth.” He raises a glass to Martje Flor, a heroine of North German folklore. A peasant girl, she silenced a horde of ransacking mercenaries with a raised glass and defiant toast. That was during the Thirty Years’ War, which to an exiled writer in 1931 was still likely the darkest chapter of German history.
“To long life and happiness!” Martje shouted at the plunderers. In Platt, of course.
Corinna da Fonseca-Wollheim is a contributing music critic for The Times.
By Kurt Tucholsky
Translated by Michael Hofmann
127 pp. New York Review Books. Paper, $14.95.
Follow New York Times Books on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram, sign up for our newsletter or our literary calendar. And listen to us on the Book Review podcast.
Source: Read Full Article